A New York City-style pepper and onion pizza at Goodfellas.

April 30, 2024 500 × 375 Sample 10 top local pizzas with our Pizza Guide

A New York City-style pepper and onion pizza at Goodfellas.

A New York City-style pepper and onion pizza at Goodfellas.

A New York City-style pepper and onion pizza at Goodfellas.

Louisville's top spot for talk and reviews from the food and restaurant scene